Sample - Evidence Review and Handoff
Up: HVE Sample Labs · Audience: Learner Personas · Evaluation: Competency and Evaluation Goals
Goal and Materials
Use HVE Samples/evidence-review/learner-packet.md to evaluate a completion claim, distinguish known defects from missing evidence, and hand off the next action. No coding environment is required for this version. Proposed time: 20–30 minutes, untested with learners.
Exercise
- Read the agreed requirements and the implementer’s completion claim.
- Identify which acceptance claims are supported by the supplied checks.
- Find one concrete counterexample to the amount-validation logic.
- Record the missing validation evidence without assuming the unseen implementation is correct or incorrect.
- Classify the client’s policy-limit request as a decision requiring clarification; do not invent a threshold.
- Write a handoff another person can resume without the prior conversation.
An assistant can help inspect or draft the review; each learner must explain the final disposition and evidence.
Required Handoff
- Agreed scope and requirement identifiers.
- Acceptance decision and its supporting evidence.
- Demonstrated defect, counterexample, and next implementation action.
- Missing evidence and the person responsible for obtaining it.
- Open policy decision and the product/client owner who must resolve it.
- Clear next step, without claiming unperformed validation.
Assessment
Look for evidence-based judgment, appropriate scope, and accountable ownership. Use Competency and Evaluation Goals. For an adaptive version, introduce a new valid requirement after the review and ask what plan/evidence must change.
Instructor key: HVE Samples/evidence-review/instructor-key.md; keep it out of learner materials. After discussion, pair reviewers with implementers from Sample - Claims Validation and repeat using actual check results.